
Will AI Replace Doctors?
AI now drafts visit notes for thousands of physicians, and one state lets it recommend routine prescription renewals. The evidence shows doctors taking on new oversight duties rather than losing their jobs, with laws and licensing boards backing that up.
No, AI is not on track to replace doctors, and we found no layoffs or hiring cuts for physicians blamed on AI. It is taking over a growing share of the paperwork and a few narrow, closely supervised tasks, and that changes what a good doctor's day looks like.
Here is the evidence behind that answer, and what it means if you are training for medicine, already practicing, or running a practice.
What the job numbers say about physicians
The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics occupational projections count 808,800 physician jobs in 2025 and project 837,900 for 2035. That is a +3.6% change, slightly ahead of the 3.5% average for all occupations.
The BLS expects 20,800 openings a year on average, and the median annual wage was $271,090 in 2025. These projections do not show a profession being hollowed out. They also do not tell us how AI will change the work inside those jobs. The rest of this page covers that question.
Where AI is already in the exam room, the chart and the prescription queue
AI has moved past the pilot stage in clinical documentation. It is also starting to make limited prescribing and imaging decisions under tight rules.
AI scribes writing visit notes
An npj Digital Medicine commentary on AI scribe risks reports that one large health system had over 7000 physicians using AI scribes in more than 2.5 million patient encounters over 14 months.
At another health system, a study in PMC describes ambient scribing going live on January 15, 2025 for over 2400 ambulatory and emergency department clinicians. By March 31, 2025, 20.1% of visit notes used it, and 1223 clinicians had tried it.
A Peterson Health Technology Institute report on AI adoption lists Intermountain Health as scaling DAX Copilot to all employed physicians and advanced practice providers. A telehealth ambient scribe paper on arXiv notes that at least 60 AI vendors were selling ambient scribing tools as of early 2025.
Uptake still varies by setting. A PubMed-indexed study of emergency department documentation found that among 198,178 encounters, only 8,489 (4.3%) used ambient AI scribes, while 15,947 (8.0%) used human scribes.
AI renewing prescriptions in Utah
Utah signed its first AI prescription renewal agreement in October 2025 with Doctronic, a digital health company, according to a Lexology analysis of Utah's healthcare AI experiment. In 2026 the Utah Department of Commerce announced that Doctronic would become "the first AI to legally prescribe routine refills."
The pilot covers 192 drugs for chronic conditions, according to JAMA Health Forum. During the first phase, a licensed physician must review each renewal, under the state's Office of AI Policy pilot page. Forbes reported that in 72% of cases, the AI recommended approval and sent the renewal to a human physician for sign-off.
Doctronic also shared a comparison of its AI with human clinicians across 500 urgent care cases with Utah regulators, as the Deseret News reported. Physicians have pushed back. On April 20, 2026, 11 of the 14 members of the Utah Medical Licensing Board signed a letter recommending that the pilot be suspended, according to Lexology. Utah still announced five new healthcare agreements under its AI sandbox on October 5, 2026.
AI signing off on normal chest X-rays
In Europe, Oxipit's ChestLink autonomously reports on chest X-rays with no abnormalities, without a radiologist involved. Hardian Health notes that the tool holds CE Class IIb certification. Sectra has agreed to acquire Oxipit, which brings autonomous AI into a mainstream imaging IT company.
A doctor's workday, task by task
| Task | What AI does today | What still needs a person |
|---|---|---|
| Writing visit notes | Ambient scribes listen to visits and draft notes at large health systems | Reviewing, correcting and signing the note, and owning what it says |
| Routine prescription renewals | In Utah's pilot, AI recommends renewals for chronic-condition drugs | A licensed physician signs off during the first phase |
| Reading normal chest X-rays | One CE-certified tool reports clearly normal films on its own | Any study with an abnormality, and the clinical context behind it |
| Coverage and medical-necessity decisions | Insurers use AI tools in utilization review | In California and Texas, a human must make the medical-necessity call |
| Diagnosis and treatment planning | AI assists, and physicians report using it in professional work | Professional judgment and ethical responsibility, per the Medical Board of California |
| Talking with patients about AI in their care | Nothing in the evidence | Informed consent and documentation, as medical board guidance urges |
Skills and specialties gaining value as AI spreads
Reviewing AI output. When AI drafts the note or recommends the refill, the physician's signature becomes the safety check. The npj Digital Medicine commentary focuses on exactly these AI scribe risks in clinical practice.
Keeping core clinical skills sharp. In the AMA's survey of nearly 1,700 physicians, 88% said they worry about skill erosion, especially among doctors with fewer than 10 years of experience, Radiology Business reported. Doctors who can still examine, reason and diagnose without the tool will stand out.
AI governance and accountability. In April 2024 the Federation of State Medical Boards adopted non-binding recommendations on AI in clinical practice, The Leveraged Years reported. The AMA launched its Center for Digital Health and AI in October 2025 to put physicians at the center of shaping these tools. Physicians who can evaluate and implement AI will help set the rules.
Complex reads over routine ones. For radiologists, autonomous tools that clear normal chest X-rays leave the abnormal and ambiguous cases to humans. Our read is that expertise in those harder cases matters more over time.
Hands-on, relationship-heavy care. The International Labour Organization's generative AI index places many health professions and hands-on roles relatively low in exposure, according to a Notre Dame ethics blog summary.
Myths vs reality for doctors
| Myth | Reality |
|---|---|
| AI already prescribes without doctors | In Utah's first phase, a licensed physician reviews each renewal, per the state's pilot page. |
| Most doctors avoid AI | 81% of physicians surveyed by the AMA use it professionally, more than double the rate in 2023, per Fierce Healthcare. In the prior survey the figure was 66%, up from 38% in 2023, per Healthcare IT News. |
| AI scribes are in every visit now | In one emergency department study, only 4.3% of encounters used them, per PubMed. |
| Insurers can let an algorithm deny care | California SB 1120 and Texas SB 815 bar AI from making the medical-necessity call, per CASRAI. California's law took effect on January 1, 2025, per The Leveraged Years. |
What to do next, depending on where you stand
- Pre-med or medical student: The BLS projects 20,800 openings a year, so medicine remains a sound path in our view. Learn the AI tools, but build your diagnostic reasoning without them, given how many physicians worry about skill erosion.
- Practicing physician: Treat every AI-drafted note and recommendation as something you are signing. Under California's Physicians Make Decisions Act, decisions to deny, delay or modify care on medical-necessity grounds stay with clinicians. Your judgment is the protected part of the job.
- Radiologist: Watch autonomous normal-study tools like ChestLink closely. Position yourself around the abnormal and complex reads.
- Health system or practice leader: Scribe adoption can lag even after launch, as the PMC study's numbers show. Plan for physician review time, training and patient consent rather than assuming the tool replaces staff.
Our verdict: AI takes the paperwork, doctors keep the decisions
We think AI will keep taking documentation and some narrow, rule-bound tasks like routine refills and normal X-ray reads. The Medical Board of California holds that AI tools generally cannot replace a physician's professional judgment, and state laws now write that into insurance decisions.
AMA CEO John Whyte said in a statement on March 12 that "AI has quickly become part of everyday medical practice," as Radiology Business reported. The AMA also says the technology should be designed to enhance physicians, not replace them, per its survey release. The fight in Utah shows that the line between assisting and deciding is still being drawn. Doctors who help draw it will shape their own future.
Questions people ask
Will AI replace doctors?
Our read is no. The BLS projects physician jobs to grow from 808,800 in 2025 to 837,900 in 2035, and the Medical Board of California says AI tools generally cannot replace a physician's professional judgment.
How many doctors use AI now?
81% of physicians surveyed by the AMA reported using AI professionally, more than double the 2023 rate. The survey reached nearly 1,700 U.S. physicians.
Can AI prescribe medication?
In Utah, Doctronic's AI can renew routine prescriptions for 192 chronic-condition drugs under a state pilot. During the first phase, a licensed physician must review each renewal.
Can an insurer's AI deny my doctor's treatment request?
California SB 1120 and Texas SB 815 bar AI tools from making the medical-necessity call in health plan utilization review. California's law took effect on January 1, 2025.
Are AI scribes used in every hospital visit?
No. One study of 198,178 emergency department encounters found that only 4.3% used ambient AI scribes, while 8.0% used human scribes.
Sources
Every number, quote and example on this page was checked by script against the sources below before publishing: quotes must match the source word for word, and figures must appear in a source or in BLS data. Our verdict is editorial judgment. Spotted an error? Tell us.
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics: Occupational projections, 2025-35 (Table 1.2)
- Beyond human ears: navigating the uncharted risks of AI scribes in clinical practice - npj Digital Medicine (nature.com)
- Checking your browser - reCAPTCHA (pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
- A Custom-Built Ambient Scribe Reduces Cognitive Load and Documentation Burden for Telehealth Clinicians (arxiv.org)
- Medical Scribe and Ambient Artificial Intelligence Impact on Emergency Physician Documentation Burden and Clinical Productivity - PubMed (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
- PHTI.org Adoption of Artificial Intelligence in Healthcare Delivery Systems: (phti.org)
- AMA survey: More doctors using (healthcareitnews.com)
- Augmented intelligence in medicine (ama-assn.org)
- More than 80% of physicians use AI professionally: AMA survey (ama-assn.org)
- AMA: Physicians' use of AI doubled from 2023 to 2026 (fiercehealthcare.com)
- AI use among American doctors has doubled, new AMA survey says (radiologybusiness.com)
- Utah’s Experiment With AI-Driven Prescription Renewals (jamanetwork.com)
- This Utah pilot program puts AI in the driver seat on patient prescription renewals (deseret.com)
- A Deep Dive into Utah’s Healthcare AI Experiment - Lexology (lexology.com)
- Office of AI Policy: Doctronic RMA - commerce.utah.gov (commerce.utah.gov)
- Utah Is Letting AI Renew Prescriptions. Here’s The Surprising Result (forbes.com)
- NEWS RELEASE: Utah and Doctronic Announce Groundbreaking Partnership for AI Prescription Medication Renewals - commerce.utah.gov (commerce.utah.gov)
- Blog Post: Which Jobs Are Most Exposed to AI and Why Exposure Is Not Destiny (ethics.nd.edu)
- AI Claim Denials: State Utilization Review Laws — CASRAI (casrai.org)
- Governor signs Physicians Make Decisions Act, keeping medical decisions between patients and doctors–not AI (sd13.senate.ca.gov)
- Healthcare AI 2025 - USA (practiceguides.chambers.com)
- California SB 1120 Puts Physicians Over AI in Coverage Calls | TLY (theleveragedyears.com)
- FSMB Recommends AI Guardrails for State Medical Boards | TLY (theleveragedyears.com)
- CE Mark for First Autonomous AI Medical Imaging Application (oxipit.ai)
- Autonomous Medical AI - to good to be true? (hardianhealth.com)
- Sectra Acquires Oxipit to Put Autonomous AI Inside Radiology (nordictech.news)